{"schemaVersion":"1.0","canonicalUrl":"https://www.iamgeorgekelly.com/field-guide/retailer-dimensions-structured-data-study","markdownUrl":"https://www.iamgeorgekelly.com/field-guide/retailer-dimensions-structured-data-study/index.md","editorialNote":"AI-assisted research and drafting. Provider-specific claims link to primary sources. Frameworks are editorial proposals; worked examples are illustrative and are not employer performance results.","publication":{"name":"iamgeorgekelly","url":"https://www.iamgeorgekelly.com"},"citation":"George Kelly. Product dimensions in structured data across four retailers iamgeorgekelly. Updated 2026-11-14. https://www.iamgeorgekelly.com/field-guide/retailer-dimensions-structured-data-study","category":"Product data","status":"published","published":"2026-11-14","updated":"2026-11-14","author":"George Kelly","slug":"retailer-dimensions-structured-data-study","title":"Product dimensions in structured data across four retailers","description":"A 12-listing audit compares visible product and package dimensions with Schema.org markup at IKEA, Ashley, World Market, and Burrow.","answer":"On November 14, 2026, all 12 sampled U.S. furniture listings showed overall product measurements. Six included product dimensions in their Schema.org markup. Five matched the visible specifications exactly across three named axes. The sixth used different labels for one axis. Six listings showed package dimensions to shoppers, and the captured Schema.org markup contained package dimensions on zero of the 12.","actions":[{"label":"Compare the retailer results","section":"findings"},{"label":"See the product and carton example","section":"product-and-package"},{"label":"Download the observations","section":"observations"}],"sections":[{"id":"findings","title":"Five complete matches across 12 listings","paragraphs":["The audit covered one side table, one bookcase, and one dining chair listing from each retailer. All 12 pages were retrieved and had a matching Schema.org Product record for the selected SKU. Every one of the 17 paired product axes was numerically equal after conversion. Five listings provided three paired axes each. The LACK side table supplied two paired axes.","Seven listings had no complete product comparison. Six lacked dimension fields in the matched Product records. One had different names for a horizontal axis. The by-retailer counts describe the sampled URLs."],"table":{"headers":["Retailer","Listings","Visible product measurements","Structured product measurements","Complete exact matches","Visible package measurements","Structured package measurements"],"rows":[["IKEA","3","3","3","2","3","0"],["Ashley","3","3","3","3","0","0"],["World Market","3","3","0","0","3","0"],["Burrow","3","3","0","0","0","0"],["Total","12","12","6","5","6","0"]]},"download":{"url":"/downloads/retailer-dimensions-study-results.json","label":"Download the counts and per-axis results (JSON)"}},{"id":"method","title":"How the pages and measurements were compared","paragraphs":["The four retailers were chosen for relevant catalogs and access to public product HTML. We fixed the 12 U.S. product URLs and comparison rules before capturing the sample. This was a convenience sample. Related products within a retailer can share a page template, so the results describe this set of listings.","We read the shopper-facing specification blocks and inspected the Schema.org markup in the same HTML responses. We matched the page’s article number or selected SKU to the Product node, following ProductGroup variants where present. The structured-data count covers JSON-LD, microdata, and RDFa in the retrieved HTML. All 12 matches used JSON-LD. Private feeds, application state, image-only values, and client-injected markup fall outside the count.","A complete comparison needs width, height, and one common named horizontal axis, with length and depth kept distinct. Conversion used exactly 25.4 mm per inch. The comparison groups were exact matches, nonexact differences up to 2 mm, and differences above 2 mm. This threshold describes displayed values."],"sources":["schema-product","schema-quantity","nist-length"],"download":{"url":"/downloads/retailer-dimensions-study-method.md","label":"Download the frozen sample and comparison rules (Markdown)"}},{"id":"units-and-axes","title":"Inch values agreed when the axis labels agreed","paragraphs":["Every observed length measurement in this U.S. sample used inches. IKEA’s Product JSON-LD used text strings with an inch mark, including fractional values. Ashley used numeric QuantitativeValue objects with the unit code INH. Both encodings preserve a unit that a reader or agent can convert.","On the LACK side table, the visible width and height matched the corresponding fields. The remaining horizontal value was 21 5/8 in on both layers. The page labeled it length and the JSON-LD called it depth. The study keeps that axis unresolved."],"table":{"headers":["Listing and axis","Shopper specification","Product JSON-LD","Comparison"],"rows":[["IKEA STEFAN height","35 3/8 in","height = 35 3/8 in as text","Exact at 898.525 mm"],["Ashley Porter width","18.88 in","width value 18.88, unitCode INH","Exact at 479.552 mm"],["IKEA LACK horizontal axis","Length 21 5/8 in","depth = 21 5/8 in as text","Axis name unresolved"]]},"sources":["ikea-lack","ikea-stefan","ashley-porter","schema-quantity","nist-length"]},{"id":"product-and-package","title":"Six shopper pages gave carton measurements","paragraphs":["All three sampled IKEA listings and all three sampled World Market listings gave package measurements in a separate specification block. None of the 12 pages supplied a package dimension in the captured Schema.org markup. The IKEA OfferShippingDetails nodes included a U.S. shipping destination and no dimension fields.","IKEA lists the assembled BILLY bookcase at 79 1/2 in high and its carton at 81 1/4 in long and 5 in high. The Product JSON-LD reproduces the assembled bookcase dimensions. A fit check needs the assembled dimensions. A carton check needs the package record and its own axis labels."],"table":{"headers":["Listing","Visible product","Visible package","Structured package"],"rows":[["IKEA BILLY","31 1/2 in W × 11 in D × 79 1/2 in H","11 3/4 in W × 81 1/4 in L × 5 in H","Absent in capture"],["World Market Campaign bookshelf","29.92 in W × 16.34 in D × 72.28 in H","71 in W × 19.6 in D × 11.25 in H","Absent in capture"]]},"links":[{"slug":"product-dimensions-unit-conversion","label":"Convert and compare dimension records","reason":"Record the item, named axes, unit, and measurement basis before using the converter."}],"sources":["ikea-billy","world-market-bookshelf","merchant-shipping"]},{"id":"observations","title":"All 12 observations and source URLs","paragraphs":["Each row records the selected item, SKU evidence, capture timestamp, response hash, visible values and labels, and the location of the matched Product node. The JSON preserves printed values, units, and package measurements, including boxes with no structured counterpart.","World Market and Burrow supplied matched Product records on all six sampled URLs, with no product dimensions in those records. For example, World Market described the Everett tabletop with a single square-side length and an overall height. The audit preserves that square-side label. The Burrow Serif page used length, width, and height for the selected walnut table and linked a SKU-specific Product node."],"sources":["ashley-galtbury","ashley-chrestner","world-market-everett","world-market-romy","burrow-serif","burrow-index","burrow-sonnet"],"download":{"url":"/downloads/retailer-dimensions-study.json","label":"Download the 12 observations, values, and source URLs (JSON)"}},{"id":"reproduce","title":"Replay the comparison from the captured facts","paragraphs":["Save the observations JSON and replay script in the same folder. Run node reproduce-retailer-dimensions-study.mjs to rebuild the counts and axis comparisons from the recorded values. The replay runs offline and preserves unresolved axes and packages. The source URLs provide a route to check any page changes after capture."],"download":{"url":"/downloads/reproduce-retailer-dimensions-study.mjs","label":"Download the offline replay script (Node.js)"}}],"sources":[{"id":"schema-product","title":"Schema.org Product","url":"https://schema.org/Product","note":"Defines item properties including width, depth, height, and additionalProperty.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"schema-quantity","title":"Schema.org QuantitativeValue","url":"https://schema.org/QuantitativeValue","note":"Defines value, unitCode, and unitText.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"nist-length","title":"NIST SI units of length","url":"https://www.nist.gov/pml/owm/si-units-length","note":"Defines the inch as exactly 25.4 mm.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"merchant-shipping","title":"Google Merchant Center shipping dimensions","url":"https://support.google.com/merchants/answer/6324498?hl=en","note":"Uses package dimensions for carrier-calculated shipping.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"ikea-lack","title":"IKEA LACK black-brown side table, article 801.042.68","url":"https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/lack-side-table-black-brown-80104268/","note":"Shows a product length and separate box dimensions. The Product node uses depth for the corresponding horizontal number.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"ikea-billy","title":"IKEA BILLY white bookcase, article 205.220.46","url":"https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/billy-bookcase-white-20522046/","note":"Shows separate Measurements and Packaging panels and Product JSON-LD.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"ikea-stefan","title":"IKEA STEFAN brown-black chair, article 002.110.88","url":"https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/stefan-chair-brown-black-00211088/","note":"Shows overall chair height, seat height, and package height in their respective contexts.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"ashley-porter","title":"Ashley Porter Chairside End Table, T697-3","url":"https://www.ashleyfurniture.com/p/porter-chairside-end-table/T697-3.html","note":"Shows overall dimensions and Product QuantitativeValue fields in inches.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"ashley-galtbury","title":"Ashley Galtbury Bookcase, A4000325","url":"https://www.ashleyfurniture.com/p/galtbury_bookcase/A4000325.html","note":"Shows matching overall bookcase dimensions in the specification and Product node.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"ashley-chrestner","title":"Ashley Chrestner Dining Side Chair, D983-01","url":"https://www.ashleyfurniture.com/p/chrestner_dining_chair/D983-01.html","note":"Lists a set of two with dimensions given for the chair.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"world-market-everett","title":"World Market Everett Wood End Table, Weathered Natural 613137","url":"https://www.worldmarket.com/p/everett-wood-end-table-129714.html?dwvar_129714_color=weatherednatural","note":"Shows an overall square-side value, overall height, and separate shipping dimensions for the selected listing.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"world-market-bookshelf","title":"World Market Wood Campaign X Back Bookshelf, 125091","url":"https://www.worldmarket.com/p/wood-campaign-x-back-bookshelf-125091.html","note":"Shows different overall bookshelf and shipping dimensions under separate headings.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"world-market-romy","title":"World Market Romy Dark Walnut Upholstered Dining Chair, 622503","url":"https://www.worldmarket.com/p/romy-dark-walnut-upholstered-dining-chair-622503.html","note":"Shows overall chair and shipping measurements. The matching Product node carries the SKU.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"burrow-serif","title":"Burrow Serif Side Table, walnut FLRTB-ST-SR-WN","url":"https://burrow.com/products/serif-side-table","note":"Shows overall dimensions and the selected walnut finish. The ProductGroup links the selected SKU.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"burrow-index","title":"Burrow Index Bookcase, oak FLRSR-BKC1-IX-OK","url":"https://burrow.com/products/index-bookcase","note":"Shows overall dimensions and the selected oak finish on the sampled configuration.","checked":"2026-11-14"},{"id":"burrow-sonnet","title":"Burrow Sonnet Dining Chairs, Papyrus/Walnut DRST-SN-S2-PY-WN","url":"https://burrow.com/products/sonnet-dining-chair-set-of-2","note":"Shows overall chair dimensions and a separate set quantity for the selected material and finish.","checked":"2026-11-14"}],"related":["product-dimensions-unit-conversion","product-dimensions-country-page-study","product-variant-url-evidence-study"]}